News 11 - Zagat Survey on Physicians

1. This week, groups G and H discussed United Health Group issues and solutions. The problems are in the physician rating system and the claims payment procedure. The insurance companies are focused mainly on cost associated with physician services with insufficient emphasis on quality.

2. Attached is a commentary on the Zagat Survey for Physicians:
http://www.healthbeatblog.org/2007/10/the-pitfalls-of.html

3. The article comments on dangers of rating physicians the same way as restaurants are rated.The author suggests a comparable experience, "It’s a bit like having car ratings only address color scheme and seat comfort: these are nice facts to know, but at the end of the day you want a car that you can rely on, a consistent performer that does its job and does it well."

I agree that the criteria on which physicians are rated in the Zagat survey is too superficial to be of significant value. Though the survey provides insight on what to expect in terms of customer service from a particular physician, it does not provide valuable information on other aspects that define the competency of a physician. Perhaps, Zagat could add value to the survey by supplementing that information with opinion and ratings supplied from an independent physician rating organization.